Skip to content

Cost coverage by AbfindungsHero (no win, no fee): is it worth it?

Cost coverage for an employment law claim

“No costs if you are dismissed”, “You only pay if you win”: promises like these are everywhere online these days. We (AbfindungsHero) offer a model like this too, because there are situations where it makes sense. But they are the exception. If you lose your job, you only have 3 weeks to challenge your dismissal in court. If you have no legal expenses insurance, do not want to apply for legal aid and want to avoid any risk of a court case, you can consider having a third party, for example AbfindungsHero, cover the costs (“no win, no fee”). An agreement like this removes the cost risk. In many cases, however, it is not the best option financially. This article explains when cost coverage, for example by AbfindungsHero (no win, no fee), is worth considering.

Key points at a glance

  • No cost risk: Under a no win, no fee agreement, we cover all lawyer and court fees in the first instance. You take no financial risk if you go to court.
  • Success-based fee: A fee is only due if you actually achieve a result (for example a severance payment), typically around 20% of the gross severance payment.
  • Legality: The model is set up so that it is permitted in Germany: it is not the lawyer who works on a success basis, but AbfindungsHero as an external party covering the costs.
  • Reality check: In many employment law cases, a no win, no fee agreement is still not worth it, because the risk in court is often limited and you give up a considerable part of your severance payment.

The problem: a cost risk despite (usually) good chances of success

Employees often have good chances before the labour courts when they challenge a dismissal with an unfair dismissal claim (Kündigungsschutzklage) and negotiate a fair severance payment. At the same time, court proceedings come with costs, and with the risk of being left with those costs if you lose after all.

After a dismissal in Germany, you only have 3 weeks to file an unfair dismissal claim. Otherwise, the dismissal automatically becomes effective. In this short time, employees have to decide whether to sue, negotiate or accept an offer. In the end, it is usually a cost-benefit decision: which option brings the best (additional) severance payment in relation to effort and costs? And do you really want to take on the risk of a court case? To answer this, it is important to understand two special features of German employment law:

  • First, in the first instance before the labour court, each party pays its own lawyer, whatever the outcome (see costs of an unfair dismissal claim).
  • Second, practice shows that many unfair dismissal cases end well for the employee. Around 81% of all claims in the first instance end in a settlement, in which the employee often receives a severance payment.

The solution: a no win, no fee agreement?

Even though the chances of a good outcome for the employee are usually good anyway, not everyone wants to take that risk.

The solution? Ideally legal expenses insurance for employment law (Rechtsschutzversicherung), which mainly covers the lawyer’s fees. The problem with legal expenses insurance is often the waiting period: cover usually only starts after 3 months (sometimes only after 6 months). If you take out a policy after receiving your dismissal, you have no cover for this case. Real legal expenses insurance without a waiting period does not exist in employment law. Exceptions apply when you switch insurers and (rarely) in certain policies, but usually only for individual services and with a cap.

Even without legal expenses insurance, there are ways to enforce your rights, for example legal aid (Prozesskostenhilfe, PKH). Or a no win, no fee agreement. If you want to rule out any remaining risk completely and have no legal expenses insurance, you pay a price for it. And it is not cheap, because providers like us (AbfindungsHero) have to price in the risk: with cost coverage by AbfindungsHero, we bear all costs of the first instance and in return only take a success-based fee if you win, which is at least 20% of the gross severance payment.

How does the AbfindungsHero model work?

At its core, our model is classic litigation funding. For selected clients, we cover all costs of the first instance, in particular the lawyer’s fees under the German Lawyers’ Remuneration Act (RVG) and the court fees. For the client, this means first of all: no financial risk if the case is lost. If the case is successful, we receive a share of the financial result. Depending on the case, this is at least 20% of the gross severance payment. The gross amount is what counts, which of course also affects the effective net burden after tax.

It also matters how “success” is defined. This includes not only classic severance payments, but also financially comparable results, such as continued employment with corresponding pay. The lawyer is secured through a separate agreement and is paid in full in line with the statutory rules, regardless of how the case ends.

The simple answer is yes. Even though the model may look like a contingency fee at first glance, it is structured differently in legal terms. The ban on contingency fees under § 49b of the Federal Lawyers’ Act (BRAO) is not circumvented, because it is not the lawyer but a third party who receives the success-based fee. The lawyer continues to bill in line with § 4a RVG. Nor does the model qualify as an insurance product. It is a permitted form of third-party funding, which has also been confirmed by case law, for example by the Higher Regional Court of Munich (OLG München).

Is it worth it?

There is no simple yes to this question. In many dismissal situations, the answer is rather no. If you have good chances of success, which is not unusual before a German labour court, and can expect a severance payment anyway, the fee means you give up a noticeable part of that result. In these situations, it often makes more financial sense to carry the limited risk yourself or to use legal expenses insurance.

Note: We very often advise people against using it. Many people are better off in the end if they carry the (small) risk of losing in court completely themselves. This is exactly what you should discuss with your lawyer before deciding on cost coverage by a third party.

Watch out for tax

A very important point: employees who receive a severance payment after losing their job have to pay tax on it. For some years now, severance payments have been fully subject to income tax, and in some cases to the solidarity surcharge and church tax as well. In total, around half of the severance payment can quickly go to the tax office. And employees in Germany unfortunately have very limited options to reduce this tax burden.

Example

An employee is dismissed after 7 years because her new manager was not satisfied with her performance. Her last salary was EUR 8,000 a month. To meet the deadline, her lawyer files an unfair dismissal claim. At the conciliation hearing (Gütetermin) before the labour court, it turns out that the dismissal is on shaky ground. After some negotiation, the parties agree on a settlement in which she receives 1.25 months’ salary for each year of employment, EUR 70,000 in total (7 years × 1.25 × EUR 8,000). In this example, her marginal tax rate is around 44%, so she initially pays a full EUR 34,000 in tax on the severance payment. On top of that comes the no win, no fee success fee of 20% of the EUR 70,000, i.e. EUR 14,000. At first, she is left with “only” EUR 22,000 net, about 30% of the severance payment. The picture improves after the income tax assessment if the success fee is recognised as work-related expenses (Werbungskosten): this results in a refund of around EUR 10,000, leaving her with EUR 32,000, about 46% of the gross severance payment of EUR 70,000.

Who is the model right for?

There are, however, situations in which our cost coverage works very well. Typically when several factors come together: an unclear starting position, no offer or a very low offer from the employer, a high potential amount in dispute and at the same time no legal expenses insurance. In such cases, the model can make the decisive difference, namely taking the step at all and enforcing your own rights. You could also say: it is a solution for risk-averse people without legal expenses insurance who would not go to court at all without cover.

What are the alternatives?

As with any financial decision, it is worth looking at the alternatives. Legal expenses insurance covers many employment law cases and removes the cost risk completely. If you have legal expenses insurance, you should definitely not sign a no win, no fee agreement. Legal aid can also offer (state) cover in certain cases. Above all, you can always conduct the proceedings at your own expense. Especially in employment law, the risk is often predictable. Many cases end in a settlement, and the costs remain manageable. In these cases, it can make financial sense to carry this risk yourself on purpose instead of outsourcing it completely.

Note: Our no win, no fee cost coverage is a deliberately narrow offer for a small target group. It creates certainty, reduces complexity and enables clients to assert their rights at all. At the same time, it is not a model for everyone. If you have very good chances of success and are prepared to carry a limited risk, you will in many cases be better off enforcing your rights without separate cover.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

What does no win, no fee mean at AbfindungsHero?

At AbfindungsHero, no win, no fee means that you do not have to pay any costs if you do not achieve a financial result. We cover the lawyer and court fees in the first instance. You normally only pay a success-based fee if you receive a severance payment or a financially comparable result.

How high is the success-based fee?

Our success-based fee is usually around 20% of the gross severance payment or a comparable financial result. As the fee is calculated on the gross amount, it affects your net payout. Depending on your tax burden, the amount you actually keep after tax can be considerably lower.

What if I use the agreement but do not get a severance payment?

If you do not achieve a result in the end, you normally do not pay anything to AbfindungsHero. That is the core of the no win, no fee approach: you carry no cost risk in the first instance, provided this is what the agreement says.

Will my severance payment be lower if I use the agreement?

The agreement does not change the severance payment you negotiate with your employer or that a court sets. It only affects your net payout, because a success-based fee is due if you achieve a result. In the end, you keep less.

Is the fee tax-deductible?

In our assessment, you can normally claim the fee paid in the event of success as work-related expenses (Werbungskosten) in your income tax return, because it is directly linked to enforcing your employment rights. What matters is that you paid it yourself and that it is work-related.

Frank Broer

Frank Broer

Frank combines legal expertise with a strong foundation in economics and business. After studying law, economics, and business administration, he began his career as a lawyer and tax advisor at the international law firm Clifford Chance. He then spent several years as a project manager…

All articles by Frank Broer

All information on our website is of an editorial nature and expressly does not constitute legal advice. Naturally, we have made every effort to ensure the accuracy of the information and links contained on this website. Nevertheless, we cannot guarantee the accuracy of the information. It is in no way a substitute for legal advice from a lawyer.

Get your free initial consultation with a lawyer

Quick callback within 1 to 2 hours. We help you enforce your rights.

  • Free initial consultation, no risk
  • Employment lawyer
  • Quick callback within 1 to 2 hours
Get your free initial consultation