Dismissal for coming late in Germany: When does it become a problem?

Many employees underestimate the consequences of being late. Regular or frequent lateness creates tension within the team and disruption in the workplace. The employer can issue a warning (Abmahnung) or, as a last resort, even dismiss an employee. In this article, we explain the consequences of a dismissal for coming late in more detail.
Key points at a glance
- A dismissal for coming late is a dismissal based on conduct (verhaltensbedingte Kündigung).
- It is only valid in cases of frequent or regular lateness (breach of duties). In most cases, written warnings are required, and the employer’s interest in terminating the employment relationship must outweigh the employee’s interest.
- A summary dismissal (fristlose Kündigung) for lateness is only justified in serious cases, where the employer cannot reasonably be expected to wait until the end of the regular notice period.
- Employees must record their working time correctly, even when they are late. False entries carry the risk of fraud (Arbeitszeitbetrug) and a summary dismissal.
Requirements for a dismissal for coming late
If the Protection Against Dismissal Act (Kündigungsschutzgesetz, KSchG) does not apply, an employer can dismiss an employee with no reason. This is the case, when the employee is working for less than six months or if he works in a small business (Kleinbetrieb) with 10 or less employees.
In case the KSchG applies (employment longer than six months and no small business), the employer can only dismiss an employee based on conduct (verhaltensbedingte Kündigung) under certain requirements:
1. requirement: breach of a contractual duty
Performing the work as agreed upon is a main obligation. Therefore, being late is basically a breach of contractual duties. The working hours are determined in an employment contract or a collective agreement (Tarifvertrag). But only significant or frequent breaches of coming late might lead to a written warning or in frequent cases to a dismissal.
The breach must be culpable, i.e. intentional or negligent. The misconduct – here, coming late – must be within the employee’s control. Here are a few examples:
- Traffic-related delays are the employee’s responsibility, since they bear the “travel risk” (Wegerisiko). Employees must factor in possible delays and plan ahead in order to arrive at work on time.
- Employees are also responsible if they overslept due to alcohol consumption or taking medication.1
- An employee is also responsible for being late if they do not hear the alarm, because they had to get up several times during the night due to their daughter’s illness. On another occasion, the same employee relied on a flat tyre on his car. The Federal Labour Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht) held the conduct is culpable and the dismissal was valid.2
- Exception: In some cases, even a non-culpable conduct can justify a dismissal based on conduct: So, the Federal Labour Court ruled that the employee had repeatedly breached his contractual duties. Even that he suffered from a mental illness, did not help, as the breaches were so frequent that the dismissal was valid.3
2. requirement: written warning
Before an employee can be dismissed for coming late, a (written) warning for the same or similar breach is required. The written warning should make the employee aware of his duties (i.e. coming on time in future) and should warn the employee that in case of another incident he must expect a dismissal. You will find more details in our article on written warnings (Abmahnung).
Written warnings can be dispensed with in a few exceptional cases. These include cases in which a change in behaviour cannot be expected in future despite a warning. Or cases in which the breach of duty is so serious that the employer obviously does not have to tolerate it.
3. requirement: balancing of interests
In the case of a dismissal for being late, the interests of the employer and the employee must be weighed against each other. The following criteria are the most relevant ones:
- Frequency of coming late: How often is the employee late?
- Severity of the breaches: the length of the delays: is it a few minutes or a few hours? Does the employee come so late, that it amounts to a “refusal to work” (e.g. the employee only turns up at the end of the shift)?
- Reasons for coming late: What were the reasons for being late? Are there exceptional circumstances (accident, moving houses, emergencies etc.)?
- Disruption to operations: How severely were operations affected by the lateness?
- Length of service: How long has the employee been with the company?
- Previous conduct: Has the employee fulfilled his duties so far? Is there a record for previous misconduct?
- Positive prognosis for the future: Is there a risk that the employee will come late in future? Do the reasons for being late fall away, e.g. the employee moves closer to the workplace, or no longer has to care for a dependent relative or attend to other family obligations, etc.
The Labour Courts take all these circumstances into account in order to decide whether the dismissal is valid or not.
Summary dismissal for being late
A summary dismissal (fristlose Kündigung) is only justified in serious cases, where the employer cannot reasonably be expected to continue the employment relationship until the end of the regular notice period. Examples of serious cases: extreme frequency of being late, severe disruptions of the workflow. A summary dismissal may, for instance, be considered where the lateness is so significant and frequent that it is coming close to a refusal to work (e.g. arriving at the end of the shift). The requirements for such a dismissal are strict.
Legal steps
Employees have the option of filing a claim against such a dismissal (Kündigungsschutzklage) before the Labour Court. This must be done within three weeks of receiving the dismissal. Legal advice from the trade union or an employment lawyer is recommended.
The Court examines whether the requirements for a valid dismissal are met.
Duty to capture the correct working time
It is important to report the lateness to your supervisor and to apologise for it, or at least to put forward good reasons. Anyone who arrives late for work should under no circumstances enter incorrect working times in order to cover up. Such conduct can be assessed as working time fraud (Arbeitszeitbetrug) and is a criminal offence. Anyone who provides false information about their attendance risks a summary dismissal. In such cases, the employer can often act even without a prior warning.
Effects on unemployment benefits
A dismissal for coming late is the result of an employee’s misconduct. For unemployment benefits (Arbeitslosengeld), this means there is “breach of insurance obligations” (“versicherungswidriges Verhalten”). If the dismissed employee had no “good reason” (“wichtiger Grund”) for the misconduct, there will be a waiting period for unemployment benefits (Sperrzeit) of up to 12 weeks. This means a reduction of unemployment benefits and a later payout.
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
An employer can dismiss an employee for coming late (dismissal based on conduct). Not every small incident justifies a dismissal. The late coming (breach of duty) must be significant or frequent. In most cases the employee must have received at least one written warning for similar incidents before. Finally, the employer’s interest in terminating the contract must outweigh the employee’s interest in continuing the employment contract.
In small businesses (10 employees or less), the Protection Against Dismissal Act (KSchG) does not apply. In these businesses, the employer can dismiss an employee without any reason. Only a summary dismissal (i.e. a dismissal with immediate effect) requires an “important reason”.
A summary dismissal for being late is only justified in serious cases, where the employer cannot reasonably be expected to continue the employment relationship until the end of the regular notice period. This is the case, where there is severe disruption to the workflow, or if the employee comes frequently late. The requirements for a summary dismissal are extremely strict.
Before an employer dismisses an employee for being late, the employer must issue a written warning for the same or similar breaches. The warning intends to inform employees on their misconduct and give them the opportunity to comply with working hours in future. A written warning can only be dispensed with where a change in behaviour cannot be expected in future or where the breach of duty is so serious that the employer obviously does not have to tolerate it.
In the case of a conduct-based dismissal, the interests of both the employer (in terminating the employment) and the employee (in continuing the contract) must always be weighed against each other. These criteria play a key role: frequency of being late, the severity of breaches (how long is the delay), reasons for the lateness (accident, emergencies), disruption to the workflow, and the employee’s previous conduct. More details in the main text above.
Employees can file an unfair dismissal claim against such a dismissal before the Labour Court. If an employee decides to do that, he must do so within three weeks of receiving the dismissal.
Employees who arrive late for work should report to their supervisor and apologise for it or at least give reasons. Under no circumstances the employee should record incorrect working times in order to cover up. Such conduct might constitute fraud and is a criminal offence.
Yes. A dismissal for being late is the result of misconduct on the part of the employee. This is usually assessed as a “breach of insurance obligations” (“versicherungswidriges Verhalten”). If the dismissed employee had no “good reason” for his conduct, a waiting period for unemployment benefits of up to 12 weeks may apply. This means a reduction of the unemployment benefits and a later payout.
All information on our website is of an editorial nature and expressly does not constitute legal advice. Naturally, we have made every effort to ensure the accuracy of the information and links contained on this website. Nevertheless, we cannot guarantee the accuracy of the information. It is in no way a substitute for legal advice from a lawyer.
Get your free initial consultation with a lawyer
Quick callback within 1 to 2 hours. We help you enforce your rights.
- Free initial consultation, no risk
- Employment lawyer
- Quick callback within 1 to 2 hours



